What are the potential drawbacks of using Robinhood's 'first in first out' feature in cryptocurrency transactions?

3 answers

• Dec 17, 2021 · 3 years ago
  One potential drawback of using Robinhood's 'first in first out' feature in cryptocurrency transactions is that it may not allow for optimal tax planning. Since FIFO requires selling the oldest purchased cryptocurrency first, it may result in higher capital gains taxes if the older coins have appreciated significantly. This can be a disadvantage for traders who want to strategically manage their tax liabilities. Another drawback is that FIFO may not be suitable for traders who employ specific trading strategies, such as short-term trading or swing trading. These strategies often require selling specific coins based on technical analysis or market conditions, rather than simply selling the oldest coins. Therefore, FIFO can limit the flexibility of these traders and potentially hinder their ability to execute their preferred trading strategies. Additionally, FIFO may not be ideal for traders who frequently engage in cryptocurrency arbitrage. Arbitrage involves taking advantage of price differences between different exchanges or markets. Since FIFO requires selling the oldest coins first, it may not allow traders to take advantage of immediate arbitrage opportunities, as they would need to wait until the oldest coins are sold before accessing the funds to execute the arbitrage. Overall, while FIFO can simplify the accounting process for cryptocurrency transactions, it may have drawbacks for traders who prioritize tax planning, employ specific trading strategies, or frequently engage in arbitrage.
  1521761
• Dec 17, 2021 · 3 years ago
  Using Robinhood's 'first in first out' feature in cryptocurrency transactions can have its downsides. One potential drawback is that it may result in missed investment opportunities. If a trader wants to sell specific coins that have recently gained value, but those coins are not the oldest in their portfolio, they would need to wait until the oldest coins are sold before accessing the funds. This delay can be frustrating and may cause traders to miss out on potential profits. Another drawback is that FIFO can lead to higher transaction fees. If a trader frequently buys and sells different cryptocurrencies, FIFO may require them to sell the oldest coins first, even if those coins have lower transaction fees. This can result in higher fees overall, as the trader may need to sell coins with higher transaction fees to access the funds they need for their desired transactions. Furthermore, FIFO may not be suitable for traders who want to strategically manage their portfolio based on market conditions. For example, if a trader believes that a specific cryptocurrency is about to experience a significant price increase, they may want to sell other coins in their portfolio to invest in that cryptocurrency. However, FIFO would require them to sell the oldest coins first, potentially preventing them from taking advantage of the anticipated price increase. In conclusion, while Robinhood's 'first in first out' feature can simplify the transaction process, it may have drawbacks such as missed investment opportunities, higher transaction fees, and limitations on portfolio management based on market conditions.
  1626542
• Dec 17, 2021 · 3 years ago
  When it comes to the potential drawbacks of using Robinhood's 'first in first out' feature in cryptocurrency transactions, it's important to consider the impact on tax reporting. FIFO can make it more challenging for traders to utilize specific tax strategies, such as tax-loss harvesting. Tax-loss harvesting involves selling investments at a loss to offset capital gains and reduce tax liabilities. However, FIFO may require selling profitable investments first, limiting the ability to strategically harvest losses and potentially resulting in higher tax bills. Another potential drawback is the lack of control over which coins are sold. With FIFO, the oldest coins are always sold first, regardless of their individual performance or potential. This can be problematic for traders who want to prioritize selling underperforming coins or holding onto promising investments. By not having the ability to choose which coins to sell, traders may miss out on opportunities to optimize their portfolio and maximize returns. Additionally, FIFO may not be suitable for traders who frequently engage in cryptocurrency staking or lending. Staking involves holding cryptocurrencies to support network operations and earn rewards, while lending involves providing cryptocurrencies to borrowers in exchange for interest. With FIFO, traders may be required to sell staked or lent coins before accessing other funds, potentially disrupting their staking or lending activities. In summary, while Robinhood's 'first in first out' feature offers simplicity in transaction handling, it may have drawbacks related to tax reporting, lack of control over coin selection, and potential disruptions to staking or lending activities.
  1716429